Is it better to see orcas in the wild or a marine park?

Is it better to see orcas in the wild or at a marine park?
The answer isn’t simple.
Recently that was the debate in a Facebook group that I’m a part of.
Marine parks have always been a subject of controversy.
Marine parks, on one hand, provide entertainment and education but on the other hand, they exploit marine life and disturb their natural behavior.
There were many answers. Some said it was that the person going to marine parks was uneducated about how the orcas were being treated at the park or the person was selfish.
Before I answered the question, I thought about what to say.
When I was in elementary school, my parents took my brother and I to Florida. My parents knew how much I loved the orca. I wanted to be an oceanographer when I was little. We ended up going to Sea World to see the orca show. I do remember that I was excited at the time.
After doing my research and seeing documentaries on how the orcas are treated, I made a vow with myself that I wouldn’t go to a marine park again.
My dad passed away recently and I was going through all the photo albums. I happened to come across the pictures of the vacation that we took to Sea World in Florida. I do remember I used to love those pictures when I was little, but now those pictures made me a little sad. I do forgive myself because I didn’t know how the orcas were treated back then.
Despite all the negative stigmas, some people still continue to support marine parks by going to the shows, buying tickets, and sharing their marine park experiences online.
One reason is that going to a marine park, guarantees that you will see marine life.
I remember one whale watching captain saying to me that in whale watching there is no guarantee that you will see any marine life. He said that this is nature and not Sea World, the animals are here to feed and not to entertain you.
When I became a travel nurse, I wanted to only go to states that I had a chance to go whale watching. I started in Florida thinking that there would be whales there. There were a lot of dolphins but no whales.
I started to do research about orca seasons in different areas. I found out that in California, you could whale watch all the time. One town in particular had an orca season. It was called Monterey Bay. Orca season is April and May and it’s known as Killer Whale Thanksgiving.
I immediately started to look for jobs that were near Monterey Bay. I found a job near Los Angeles. I found out that I could take a train to get to Monterey from Los Angeles. I also found a whale watching company in Newport Beach that was operating year round.
The first thing that I did when I got to my job was to go whale watching in Los Angeles. I didn’t see anything when I went. I was disappointed but I wouldn’t give up. Someone told me that to see the whales, I needed to go to Newport Beach.
I did some research and found a company that I liked. It wasn’t far from where I was working, so I decided to go at least once a week. I got to know the crew very well.
As I started to go whale watching, I started to see more whales and dolphins.
One time, I had a day off. I was tired so I didn’t go whale watching that day. I happened to see on the news that night, that there had been orcas in Newport Beach. To say I was sad was an understatement.
The crew knew that orcas were my favorite animal. I did get to see all their videos. They got to see the orcas on all of their trips that day.
But like the captain said there is no guarantee. That uncertainty may lead some people to go to a marine park where you are guaranteed to see marine life.
When I finally had 3 days in a row off from work, I decided to go to Monterey Bay. It was orcas season and I was excited to see orcas in the wild for the first time.
I took the Amtrak train to get to Monterey Bay.
I only had 2 days because I wanted to make it back to Los Angeles on my third day. The first 2 days, we only saw humpback whales. While I was grateful that we were seeing some whales, I really wanted to see orcas.
After the second day, I had to make some decisions. I changed my train ticket and had to find another Airbnb to stay in. I was determined to see orcas. I also asked the whale watching company if there was any space on the next days whale watching trip. At the time, there were no more spaces.
I was disappointed but she said that there may be some cancellations in the morning.
I woke up early and waited for that phone call. At 7:05 am, I got the call. There had been a cancellation and I had a spot.
On this very day, April 21, 2018, my dreams came true. I got to see orcas in the wild!! It is my 5 year orcaversary!!
Most people also don’t know that if you don’t see any marine life on a whale watching tour, the company will give you a voucher. The voucher will either be a free whale watching tour or a heavy discount for your next whale watching tour.
Another reason that people may choose marine parks is convenience. Every body doesn’t have the luxury to extend their vacation like I did. It can be difficult and expensive to plan a whale watching tour, especially if you don’t live near the ocean.
Marine parks do provide a chance to see multiple species, which might be impossible to do while whale watching.
Also for families with young kids, whale watching might not be an option, making marine parks more convenient for them.
There are also ethical concerns about marine parks.
Orcas are very social animals. They live in matriarchal societies. Some male orcas don’t leave their mother until their death. In some research, if a mother orca dies, the son may die soon after.
In captivity, they are confined to small pools and forced to perform for their food. They are made to do the same thing day after day. The stress can lead to health issues, mental issues, and even premature death.
Each of us have a choice and a decision to make by weighing the pros and cons of going to a marine park. Find a marine park that upholds high standards of animal welfare. Look for parks that prioritize conservation, education, and research.
If you are planning a whale watching tour, be aware that there are no guarantees of seeing marine life. To me that is what makes whale watching special. If you see any marine life, then it was meant to be.
Even when I don’t see any marine life when I go whale watching, I can still enjoy a day at sea.
In conclusion, the reasons why people choose to go to marine parks are complex and varied. It’s not fair to judge or condemn someone for their choices. It’s very important to have honest and open discussions about the ethics of keeping orcas in captivity. By understanding the reasons behind our choices, we can make informed decisions and work towards a future where orcas are protected and respected.